I just received it today. I am 5'11' and 160lb and the Medium is a good fit but very much a tailored fit as far as sweatshirts go.
Pros: a lot of (vintage??) details including longer wrist and waist ribbing; side panels, double metal zipper, perfect sized/shaped double layered hood, retro style label, and the less common French terry material (noticeable on the underside especially); 100% cotton (a big personal preference for me).
Neutral: salt and pepper color is not nearly as pronounced as in the picture; the pouch pockets are smallish.
Con: it is advertised as "18oz French Terry" which would make one think it's a very heavy weight 600+ gsm 'winter hoodie' (when a heavyweight is typically 13oz psy or 440 gsm or greater) but it feels very much middleweight to me so deducted a star as I find it somewhat misleading.
Overall assessment: at the sale price, I am satisfied but would expect it to be heavyweight at the regular price. I think TS was going for a vintage feel and look here which I is quickly growing on me.